Hot Water Heater Repair: Quick Fixes for Property Owners

Picture of Jamie Gardner - Founder & Electrician at Home Exeter

Jamie Gardner - Founder & Electrician at Home Exeter

Jamie founded Home Exeter in 2019 and has been a working electrician for over a decade. He leads a NICEIC-accredited team serving Exeter and South Devon.

Picture this: you wake up, stumble to the shower, and are greeted with a blast of ice-cold water. Your hot water heater has called it quits – and if you’re anywhere in Exeter or the surrounding Devon towns, you’ll want it sorted fast. What was once a reliable source of warm showers and clean dishes is now a source of stress. Fear not. A hot water heater repair doesn’t have to be a painful experience. This guide covers everything renters and homeowners alike need to know – DIY or expert, a range of common issues and solutions, cost-effective fixes, pro tips, and guidance on finding reliable local plumbers, including our own Gas Safe registered engineers here in the local area.

Common Water Heater Issues (and how to diagnose them)

Diagnosing the root of your hot water problem is the first step toward a fix. Here’s a breakdown of common issues, from easily resolvable to requiring professional help:

1. No Hot Water Whatsoever?

Before panicking, check your circuit breaker. Electric water heaters sometimes trip breakers if they are overloaded. If a breaker has tripped, carefully switch it back to the “ON” position.

However, if it trips again, contact a qualified electrician to investigate. For gas water heaters, ensure the pilot light is lit. If relighting the pilot doesn’t work or you smell gas, turn off the gas immediately and call a Gas Safe registered engineer. Never attempt gas-related repairs unless you are qualified – always prioritise safety.

2. Not Enough Hot Water?

Several factors could be at play:

  • Water Heater Size: A tank that’s too small for your household’s needs will run out quickly. It might be time for an upgrade to a larger water tank.
  • Sediment Build Up: This is a common problem, especially in areas with hard water. Over time, minerals accumulate in the bottom of your tank, hindering its heating efficiency. Regularly flushing your water heater can help prevent this .
  • Faulty Heating Elements (Electric Heaters): Like any electrical component, heating elements can fail. Testing them with a continuity tester will reveal if they need replacement. This is a job usually best left to a professional, especially if you lack experience with electrical work.

3. Water Too Hot (or Not Hot Enough)?

If your water temperature isn’t what you expect, chances are it’s a thermostat issue. Carefully adjust the thermostat settings; lower it if the water’s too hot or raise it slightly if it’s lukewarm.

Consult your owner’s manual for recommended settings based on your water heater model. Always wait a few hours after adjustments to check the temperature again as tanks take time to heat up or cool down. If you are uncomfortable adjusting thermostat settings, a qualified plumber can make adjustments safely and accurately.

4. Leaky Water Heater

A leak is a definite sign of trouble and requires immediate attention to prevent water damage and potential safety hazards. Here’s what to do if you discover your water heater is leaking:

  • Determine the Location: This will indicate what needs repair. Is the water leaking from the top, the T&P relief valve, or the bottom of the water heater?
  • Water Leaking From the Top: It could signal a loose pipe connection or a faulty inlet valve, often fixable with simple tightening or replacement.
  • Water Dripping from the Temperature/Pressure (T&P) Relief Valve?: This could mean excessive pressure inside the tank. If simply replacing the T&P valve doesn’t stop the leak, there could be a more serious underlying issue, and professional repair becomes essential.
  • Water Leaking From the Bottom: This usually signifies a leaking tank and spells bad news, often requiring a full replacement of the entire water heater. Water stains on the tank or the floor surrounding it are telltale signs.

DIY Hot Water Heater Repair: When It Is (and Isn’t) a Good Idea

While certain water heater repairs are relatively straightforward and can be handled with some DIY spirit, others absolutely demand the expertise of a licensed plumber. Understanding the difference can save you from headaches (and potentially dangerous situations).

DIY-Friendly Repairs

Consider these repairs only if you’re comfortable with basic plumbing and have reviewed your owner’s manual. Even seemingly simple repairs should never be attempted if they exceed your skillset.

  1. Relighting the Pilot Light: Instructions vary by model, so consult your water heater manual for specific instructions.
  2. Tightening Loose Connections: Carefully inspect visible pipes and fittings for drips or signs of looseness, gently tightening them with a pipe wrench.

Call a Plumber.

Anything more than the basic tasks listed above is best left to certified experts, especially when dealing with:

  • Gas Leaks: These are extremely hazardous, requiring immediate evacuation of your home and calling your gas utility. If you smell gas, do not attempt to fix this problem yourself.
  • Electrical Issues: Tampering with wiring or components within the electrical system of a hot water heater without proper training risks severe electric shocks. Always disconnect power at the circuit breaker before working on your electric water heater, and do not proceed if you are uncomfortable doing so.
  • Leaking Tanks: These often require a complete replacement of your water heater—a major job requiring professional installation. This is not a DIY repair.

Preventative Measures: Give Your Water Heater Some Love

Just like your car, your water heater thrives on regular maintenance to stay in top shape. Proactive care helps prevent issues from arising in the first place:

Annual Flushing:

This simple task removes sediment build-up, which can hinder the efficiency of your water heater. Turn off the power to the unit, close the cold water inlet valve, attach a garden hose to the drain valve, direct the hose to a suitable drainage location, open the valve and let the water drain completely. Consult your owner’s manual for specific steps as instructions may vary based on the model and brand of your water heater.

Check the Anode Rod:

A sacrificial anode rod protects your tank from corrosion, extending its life span. Inspect and replace it every 3-5 years (or as needed, especially in areas with hard water). An inexpensive anode rod is well worth the investment, potentially adding years to your current water heater.

Test the T&P Relief Valve

Periodically test the T&P valve by lifting and releasing its lever. This will help ensure your water heater is functioning properly. If water doesn’t flow or flows continuously, the valve may be faulty and need replacement to ensure the safe operation of your water heater.

Despite your best efforts, there comes a time when every hot water heater meets its demise and replacement becomes the most practical course of action. Knowing what to expect makes the transition smoother.

Choosing the Right Water Heater

Factors to consider when selecting a new unit include:

  • Fuel Source: Weigh the pros and cons of gas vs. electric options, factoring in availability and your budget. Do you want a gas water heater or an electric water heater?
  • Tank Size: Your hot water needs and household size influence tank size. Consider how much hot water you use on a daily basis.
  • Energy Efficiency: High-efficiency models (while pricier upfront) often mean long-term energy bill savings. Consider their overall lifecycle cost. An energy-efficient water heater can save you money over time.

Finding a Reputable Installer

Opting for a qualified, licensed installer is non-negotiable for your new water heater. Always:

  • Check References and Online Reviews: Look for an installer with positive reviews and ask for references from past clients.
  • Request Multiple Quotes: Don’t be afraid to shop around for competitive pricing. Get quotes from at least three different installers. You can get one from us by getting in touch!
  • Insist on Proper Permits: Ensure the installer obtains all necessary permits before beginning the installation.
  • Ensure Compliance with All Codes: Any new water heater installations should meet all applicable codes for safety and optimal operation.

Hot Water Heater Repair FAQs

Is it worth it to repair a hot water heater?

Repairing your hot water heater can be worth it, especially if it’s a relatively new and well-maintained unit, and the repair is minor. However, if your heater is old, has a history of problems, or requires extensive repairs, replacement might be the more cost-effective option in the long run. Consider factors such as the age of your heater, the cost of repairs, and the price of a new unit.

Why is my hot water heater not heating up?

Several factors could be at play. For electric water heaters, common culprits include a tripped breaker, a faulty thermostat, a broken heating element, or loose wiring. For gas water heaters, issues with the gas supply, a malfunctioning thermostat, or a faulty thermocouple could be to blame. Troubleshooting these issues often requires some electrical or plumbing know-how. If you are not comfortable working with gas or electricity, contact a qualified technician.

Is it hard to fix a hot water heater?

The difficulty varies widely. Some fixes, like relighting the pilot light or tightening a loose connection, can be easy and manageable for those with basic DIY skills. However, other repairs, such as replacing a heating element, fixing a gas leak, or addressing a leaking tank, are complex and potentially dangerous. These repairs demand the expertise of a qualified plumber. Attempting them yourself without proper knowledge and training can worsen the problem, lead to safety hazards, or even void your warranty.

Can you patch up a hot water heater?

While you might temporarily patch a small leak in the pipes or fittings, it’s generally inadvisable and often unsafe to try “patching up” the tank itself. Patching a tank is a temporary fix that can lead to more significant issues down the line. If your tank is leaking, it’s best to consider a replacement to avoid bigger issues (and a flooded house) in the long run. A new water heater provides peace of mind and ensures a reliable hot water supply.

Conclusion

Remember, although tackling hot water heater repair can seem intimidating, being equipped with information empowers you. Now you’re armed with the knowledge to troubleshoot, decide between DIY and calling in a pro, and ensure your hot water keeps flowing smoothly for years to come. Understanding potential issues and following basic maintenance goes a long way toward a stress-free hot water experience.

Like this article? Share it...
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Get a free estimate